top of page
TCS_horizontal.png

Submission Details
 

Impact Write-Up

The Center Square’s investigation into Washington’s new millionaire’s tax uncovered nearly 1,000 pages of internal communications between the Washington Attorney General’s Office and legislative leaders that shed new light on the purpose behind the proposal. Through public records requests, The Center Square obtained emails showing lawmakers and state attorneys discussing strategies to prompt the Washington Supreme Court to reconsider nearly a century of precedent holding that income is property under the state constitution. The records included communications in which Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen stated he wanted to “force” the court to revisit the 1933 Culliton decision and legal advice from state attorneys on how to structure the tax to maximize the likelihood of overturning existing case law.

 

After publication, attorneys challenging the tax cited The Center Square’s findings in a supplemental brief before the Washington Supreme Court, arguing the records contradicted the state’s legal position in litigation. The initial investigation also led to additional records requests that uncovered further communications involving Attorney General’s Office staff, including discussions about legal strategy surrounding efforts to block a voter referendum on the tax. Those follow-up stories expanded public scrutiny of both the tax and the government officials involved.

 

The Center Square’s series generated significant statewide and national attention. The Wall Street Journal’s editorial board cited The Center Square’s findings in an editorial examining the court’s decision to block a referendum. Seattle radio program The Gee & Ursula Show discussed the reporting with Sen. Pedersen, while Fox 13, MyNorthwest, and the Washington Policy Center produced follow-up coverage based on The Center Square’s reporting. The Center Square’s reporters were also interviewed on multiple regional programs, including the Ari Hoffman Show, the Lars Larson Show, and the John Curley Show on KIRO Radio.

 

Across four stories, The Center Square’s series generated 33,000 website views and 400,000 social media views. The articles were republished 714 times by news outlets in 47 states, including 37 times in Washington state. By obtaining exclusive records, prompting new legal arguments in an active court case, and driving broader media coverage, The Center Square provided taxpayers with information that otherwise would not have entered the public record.

Staff Submission

 This story was the result of the State Attorney General's Office turning over 988 pages of unredacted attorney client privileged communications between the AGO, the governor, and the prime sponsor for the millionaire's tax. The unredacted emails make it explicitly clear the purpose of the tax was not to collect revenue, but "force" the State Supreme Court to overturn 90 years of legal rulings that prohibit a progressive income tax.

 

This exclusive story has garnered significant media coverage – including a WSJ editorial – as well as a total shift in discussions around the tax, as it can no longer be defended at face value. Further, the initial story led to other public records requests that provided additional unredacted attorney client privileged communications by a former State Supreme Court clerk that call into question the court's impartiality. My story was also used as supplementary material in a lawsuit against the new tax's necessity clause, which prevents a referendum on the matter. 

 

The series could also have implications for the AGO moving forward due to them publicly commenting on confidential communication without their client’s consent. It is on that basis I obtained unredacted confidential emails after appealing their redaction with the Secretary of State’s Office. The series has transformed the narrative around the initiative to get the income tax repealed and has brought needed scrutiny on elected officials who we now know are scheming to get around the Constitution and the will of taxpayers.

bottom of page